Skip to comments.ANTHONY BROWNE: Waste your life, learn to speak a foreign language
Posted on 12/23/2002 6:41:07 AM PST by MadIvan
We all know le problème: we are a nation of monoglots, linguistically challenged and so culturally inferior and economically constrained. Only one in four of us can claim to speak in foreign tongues, whereas our chic European chums babble away in a veritable Babel. European governments have lobbied, and the British Government has responded: from 2010 every primary school shall teach foreign. Its a further good intention paving the road to ruin of our education system. We should shrug off our linguistic hang-ups, and instead of reinforcing language teaching, abolish it tout de suite.
Ordering everyone to learn another language is as pointless as ordering everyone to dig holes and fill them up. The reward for our ancestors persuading the rest of the world to speak English is that there is no need for us to learn what the rest of the world speaks.
All the time we spend learning another language, we should spend instead learning something useful like economics, business studies, politics, law or computer science. If everyone in the country were forced to study economics as remorselessly as they are forced to learn French, then Britain would be in a far better state (true reform of the NHS would have happened decades ago).
Learning another language may make you feel clever, but it is no longer necessary for speaking with the foreigners youre most likely to want to speak to: the educated and those working in tourism. Ever regretted you didnt spend years learning German because of problems communicating with German labourers? I thought not.
I spent three hours a week for six years learning French, but it has proved a total waste of time. I have only needed it on a handful of occasions, and even then it was tourist French learnable in a couple of weeks. I have family friends in France, and have had many enjoyable conversations with our Gallic neighbours, but always in English. I have extended family in Norway and Denmark, but hardly speak either language because I never get the chance: all my Scandinavian relatives speak perfect English.
In contrast to all our continental cousins, Britain is part of the Anglosphere, by far the most powerful linguistic bloc in the world: the US, the UK, Canada, Australia, Ireland and New Zealand as well as countries such as South Africa and India where English is the language of business and politics. Three of the G7 countries are anglophone.
Even outside the Anglosphere you can thrive with impunity as an English monoglot: you can work with no problems in the European Commission, the European Central Bank and countless multinational companies around the world. There is no obvious alternative language French is only useful in a couple of developed countries and North Africa, and Spanish helps you on holiday in Cuba.
Dont get me wrong: I understand the smug satisfaction of mastering another tongue, but it is damaging to force it on the entire population. European children spend 15 per cent of their time learning foreign languages by the age of ten imagine the advantages we would have if our kids did something more interesting in that time than learning how to ask for un café.
The Government is swimming against the tide of history: as more people learn English, the more pointless it is for Britons to learn another language. There are fewer and fewer people in the world worth speaking to who dont speak English. Already the number of people studying languages at A level in Britain is plummeting.
The Governments recent announcement that it is no longer compulsory to learn a foreign language up to GCSE is a welcome dose of reality. But it should go the whole hog, and stop forcing everyone to learn useless knowledge that they will never need, and hardly ever use.
.. and learned just enough to converse with a five-year old German child the only time I was ever reasonably successful in using it.
Otherwise, I knew just enough to get myself in trouble trying to speak to real Germans.
Although I was pretty good with "ein schnitzel mit pommes frites" and "ein bier, bitte" ... not to mention "Wo is der Bahnhof?"
I do beg to differ slightly about the value of learning a second language. Learning French has taught me more about the roots and structure of English than I ever learned in class. I think I am a better writer in English because of my studies in French.
French also helps with the cooking. Good chocolate, ne-c'est-pas? (No ne-c'est-pas, Hershey's)
Garde la Foi, mes amis! Nous nous sommes les sauveurs de la République! Maintenant et Toujours!
(Keep the Faith, my friends! We are the saviors of the Republic! Now and Forever!)
LonePalm, le Républicain du verre cassé (The Broken Glass Republican)
Latin helps you understand grammar, and opens up the world of antiquity. Also, studies have shown that American students who learn Latin have higher SAT scores.
So, let's abolish French on the curriculum and put back in Latin and perhaps Ancient Greek.
*cough*...ahem. And Irish! ;-)
The tourist asked the same question, but this time in German. Again, the Americans shook their heads sympathetically and apologized. The tourist tried asking the question in Spanish, then Italian, and finally in Russian, without any success. Finally, he threw up his hands in exasperation and walked away.
"It really is a shame that we Americans are so ignorant," one man said to the other, "We really should make an effort to learn foreign languages so we can communicate with people from other countries."
"Why bother?" the other man said, "Look at that poor bastard -- he spoke five different languages, but it didn't do him any good!"
We need an English only law....
Well, that is reason alone not to learn another language.
With French and German, there is no level of proficiency that any Anglophone is likely to attain, that will result in anything more than being laughed at and thought pathetic, and having the nearest English speaker called over.
With Spanish, it is useful right here at home, has all the educational advantages of Latin as far as etymology etc...and yet opens a whole new world south of the border, where it often IS really needed...now if they would just make Portuguese more similar to it, so that really it might do even in Brazil...
Oh BTW it seemed to be surprisingly useful even in ITALY! What was I saying about it being basically just Latin?
I suffered through six years of Spanish and the only thing I know how to say is "I wish to drink all your beer and make love to your sister".
I have to say that experience has taught me you're probably better off NOT knowing how to say that.
Guns Before Butter.
Semper ubi sub ubi!
"We have no fear of the Hottentot, for we've the Maxim gun, and they do not"
Teasing the good old froggy's is such fun.
Regards, and have a great holiday. Hope you get what you want on Boxing Day.
What an astute observation. I no longer encourage students/adults to learn foreign language as it is truly a waste of time. Mostly, it wastes my time as I have to work too hard to teach them when they don't want to learn.
I would say something about the uselessness of French AND German in the U.S. as we are demographically overrun with Spanish-speaking individuals who have little or no interest in learning English, but I'd get flamed.
Shhhhhh...don't tell anybody what's happening. It will make them angry.
That type of effect and cause logic would make any liberal happy. :-).
Through watching foreign films and carefully reading the subtitles, I am making progress on understanding the native language of another country. I'm just confused about why they call their language English. It barely sounds like the language I speak. Fortunately, I am able to decipher some of the words when spoken slowly and clearly.
After three years of high school German, I still remember more German from Hogan's Heros reruns than from school.
For me, yes, mo mhile gra. But not for everyone. ;)
Je suis American--I am an American.
Je pa parle Francais--I don't speak French (Yes, I know it's ungrammatical, but my French-Canadian brother-in-law assures me that it's understandable).
Parlez vous Anglais, le langue du monde?--Do you speak English, the world language? (They're not going to like you anyway, so let's rub it in!)
Tigim leat go hiomlan.
I don't agree with the premise that modern language study is a waste of time. Requiring all students in high school to take a foriegn language is a waste of time, but on an individual basis, acquiring speaking knowledge of another language is a very rewarding experience. I think Mark Twain said," Acquiring another language is like getting another soul". He learned German late in life like I did.
He also said something to the effect that one had to wait for the second act of a Wagnerian opera to get to the verb.
I also believe that language shapes an individual's perception of the world. The exactitude of the German language parallels and probably accounts for their renowned precision.
The most widely spoken language in the world is and will always be broken English, however. For non-English speakers, learning some English is a must.
And also, our refusal to speak any other language drives the French and Germans absolutely barmy. ;)
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.